Examiner Michelle Crowell

Grant ratio: 38.2% (45th percentile in Art Unit 1716 among examiners with at least 20 applications). Average office actions per grant: 2.44. Most common rejection type: §103.

Recently active Last office action in data: November 2026
Grant ratio 38.2%
Average office actions / grant 2.44
Compared with Art unit About average
Compared with Work group Very hard
Compared with Technology center Very hard
Compared with USPTO Very hard

Examiner record

Examiner ID
78945
Primary art unit
1716
Work group
1710
Technology center
1700
Applications
484
Granted applications
185
Examiner phone
(571) 272-1432
Supervisor
Parviz Hassanzadeh
Supervisor phone
(571) 272-1435

Save this analysis

Download this examiner report.

Log in / Sign Up to export

Peer comparisons

GroupExaminersAverage grant ratioAverage office actions / grant
Art Unit 22 39.3% 2.46
Group 168 44.8% 2.19
Tech Center 1,825 43.0% 2.14
USPTO 16,679 51.5% 1.98

Office actions per application

Average office actions per application 2.64 1,280 office actions across 484 applications
Applications with office actions 100.0% 484 applications
Office actionsApplicationsShare of applications
No OA observed 0 0.0%
1 OA 137 28.3%
2 OAs 148 30.6%
3 OAs 77 15.9%
4 OAs 62 12.8%
5+ OAs 60 12.4%

Each application is counted once. “5+” includes all higher counts.

Grant history

0.0% 25.0% 50.0% 75.0% 100.0% 2008: 46.2% 2008 2009: 42.9% 2009 2010: 33.3% 2010 2011: 34.8% 2011 2012: 45.5% 2012 2013: 23.3% 2013 2014: 28.0% 2014 2015: 31.6% 2015 2016: 40.0% 2016 2017: 55.6% 2017 2018: 45.5% 2018 2019: 53.8% 2019 2020: 42.1% 2020 2021: 39.1% 2021 2022: 53.8% 2022 2023: 81.3% 2023 2024: 58.3% 2024 2025: 22.6% 2025 2026: 0.0% 2026

Recent ratios may be lower while applications remain pending.

Yearly counts
YearApplicationsGrantsGrant rate
200813646.2%
2009351542.9%
201027933.3%
201123834.8%
2012331545.5%
201330723.3%
201425728.0%
201519631.6%
201620840.0%
2017271555.6%
2018221045.5%
2019261453.8%
202019842.1%
202123939.1%
2022261453.8%
2023161381.3%
2024241458.3%
202531722.6%
20264500.0%

Rejections by office-action stage

Office-action stageActions observed§101§102§103§112
Action 1 484 0.2% 8.1% 71.5% 0.6%
Action 2 347 0.0% 3.7% 79.0% 0.6%
Action 3 199 0.0% 1.0% 83.9% 1.5%
Action 4 122 0.0% 0.0% 87.7% 0.0%
Action 5 60 0.0% 0.0% 90.0% 0.0%
Action 6 37 0.0% 0.0% 89.2% 2.7%
Action 7 14 0.0% 7.1% 85.7% 0.0%
Action 8 9 0.0% 0.0% 88.9% 0.0%
Action 9 3 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0%
Action 10 3 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 0.0%

Section 101 rejections

Last 3 years 0.0% 0 of 198 office actions
All years 0.1% 1 of 1,280 office actions
Change -0.1 pts Percentage points

Last 3 years: 2023-11-13–2026-11-13. All years includes every dated office action in the data.

By year

0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
2014: Alice
0.0%
0.0%
1.1%
0.0%
0.0%
2019: PEG
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
2024: AI examples
0.0%
2025: August memo
0.0%
0.0%

Each bar is the percentage of office actions with a §101 rejection.

PTAB appeals

Matched decisions: 19. Merits outcomes: 11 affirmed, 0 affirmed in part, and 8 reversed.

Full reversal rate
42.1% 8/19 decisions
Full or partial reversal rate
42.1% 8/19 decisions
Median appeal duration
14.5 months
New grounds of rejection
0
Recent decisions
DecisionApplicationOutcomeIssues
Aug. 26, 2026 16/720,087 Affirmed §103
Apr. 15, 2026 17/718,427 Affirmed §103 · §112
Feb. 20, 2026 16/167,074 Affirmed §103
Jan. 28, 2026 17/333,790 Reversed §103
Dec. 26, 2023 15/828,112 Affirmed §103 · §112
May. 5, 2022 15/954,903 Reversed N/A
Jan. 11, 2022 15/521,645 Affirmed N/A
Mar. 25, 2020 13/147,724 Reversed §103
Mar. 2, 2020 13/934,624 Reversed §103
Jun. 24, 2019 13/889,478 Reversed §103
May. 10, 2019 13/793,454 Affirmed §103 · §112
Dec. 14, 2018 14/522,196 Reversed §103

The examiner match uses the last recorded office action before the decision. Reversal rates exclude rehearings, remands, dismissals, and other decisions that did not reach the merits. Data through Nov. 20, 2026.

Job History

These are temporarily preserved for your convenience, but expire quickly for your security. We never save substantive inputs, pasted text, and/or uploaded files.

Jobs will appear here.